Bogus Complaint about Non-Playing of Israeli National Anthem

Newspapers around the world are carrying the story that arose when a Minister of Israel complained that the Israeli National Anthem was not played for an Israeli girl who won the prize for Best Girl Under-14 at the World Youth Chess Championships in Turkey last week.

This complaint is bogus. At the World Youth Chess Championships in Turkey it was decided to dispense with the national anthems. There were prizes to be awarded for the best boy and girl under the ages of 18, 16, 14, 12, 10 and 8 for a total of twelve first prizes in all, not counting the second and third prizes. The organizers decided that it would take 90 minutes to play all these national anthems and all the kids and their parents would get bored and leave. Therefore no national anthems were played.

The Israeli Minister who is complaining about the Israeli National Anthem not being played in Turkey looses credibility for himself and his country by making this nonsense complaint.

Sam Sloan
New York

This isn’t a USCF issue.

Can this thread be moved to the “All Things Chess” forum?

– Randy Shane

This subject is likely to be controversial. This story is being blasted all over the world. The newswires are apparently carrying it. I think it is best that it stay here.

And yes, Mr. Policeman, the World Youth Championships in Turkey are a USCF Issue.

Sam Sloan

Relax. Ministers including our own complain about silly stuff all the time.

No one really cares. I don’t think Israel and Turkey will go to war over it. They are actually sometimes close allies.

Controversial doesn’t make it a USCF issue. The presence of USCF members at an event such as the World Youth Championships doesn’t necessarily make all controversy at an event an USCF issue, especially when USCF members aren’t even involved in the controversy.

Besides, this topic has been moved. Having some structure is a good thing.

– Randy Shane

This story is all over the world. It is in the Philadelphia Inquirer today.

It caused me to miss something truly important, like America’s Most Wanted last night.

One major newspaper that I know about has refused to carry the story, perhaps for the reason that I gave.

Sam Sloan

Just looking back… obviously this story didn’t go very far. I guess most editors immediately, or eventually, came to the same conclusion as did Sam.

A non-incident. Pure canardization.